WTO Dispute Settlement: General Appreciation and the Role of India

ICFAI University Press, WTO and Dispute Resolution, Hyderabad (India), K. Padmaja, ed., pp. 147-201, 2007

61 Pages Posted: 14 Sep 2007

See all articles by Thomas A. Zimmermann

Thomas A. Zimmermann

University of St. Gallen - Swiss Institute for International Economics and Applied Economic Research; Catholic University of the Sacred Heart of Milan - ASERI (Alta Scuola di Economia e Relazioni Internazionali - Postgraduate School of Economics and International Relations); SECO, State Secretariat for Economic Affairs, Switzerland

Abstract

On 1 January 1995, the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (DSU) entered into force. Until August 2006, the DSU has since been applied to 348 complaints - more cases than dispute settlement under the GATT 1947 had dealt with in nearly five decades. The system is perceived, both by practitioners and in academic literature, to work generally well. However, it has also revealed some flaws. Negotiations to review and reform the DSU have been taking place since 1997 (DSU review), however, without yielding any result so far. In the meantime, WTO Members and adjudicating bodies managed to develop the system further through evolving practice. While this approach may remedy some practical shortcomings of the DSU text, the more profound imbalance between relatively efficient judicial decision-making in the WTO (as incorporated in the DSU) and nearly blocked political decision-making evolves into a serious challenge to the sustainability of the system.

This article provides an overview of the first eleven years of DSU practice and the current DSU review negotiations. An outlook for future challenges to the system is also given. Moreover, specific chapters of the text focus on the role of India in WTO dispute settlement, her use of the system and her participation in the DSU review negotiations.

Keywords: International Trade, Trade Policy, WTO, Dispute Settlement, Dispute Settlement Understanding, DSU Review Negotiations, India

JEL Classification: F02, F13, K33, K41

Suggested Citation

Zimmermann, Thomas A., WTO Dispute Settlement: General Appreciation and the Role of India. ICFAI University Press, WTO and Dispute Resolution, Hyderabad (India), K. Padmaja, ed., pp. 147-201, 2007, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1014355

Thomas A. Zimmermann (Contact Author)

University of St. Gallen - Swiss Institute for International Economics and Applied Economic Research ( email )

SIAW-HSG
Bodanstrasse 8
St. Gallen, SG 9000
Switzerland

HOME PAGE: http://www.zimmermann-thomas.ch

Catholic University of the Sacred Heart of Milan - ASERI (Alta Scuola di Economia e Relazioni Internazionali - Postgraduate School of Economics and International Relations) ( email )

18, via San Vittore
Milano (Milan), MI 20123
Italy

HOME PAGE: http://aseri.unicatt.it/faculty/thomas_a_zimmermann

SECO, State Secretariat for Economic Affairs, Switzerland ( email )

Holzikofenweg 36
Berne, BE 3003
Switzerland
+41584632400 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.seco.admin.ch