Genetic Testing and the Puzzles We are Left to Solve (a): Consideration for Family Members
1 Pages Posted: 21 Oct 2008
There are 2 versions of this paper
Genetic Testing and the Puzzles We are Left to Solve (a): Consideration for Family Members
Abstract
This set of cases (labeled A through M [UVA-E-0192 through UVA-E-0203]) presents various vignettes, each with a specific dilemma about genetic testing and the ethical issues and difficult decisions that this testing presents to patients, doctors, employers and employees. UVA-E-0204 is a technical note about genetic testing which provides background and information on the issues.
Excerpt
UVA-E-0191
GENETIC TESTING AND THE PUZZLES
WE ARE LEFT TO SOLVE (A)
Consideration for Family Members
A 39-year-old man, Willy, and his 19-year-old son, Thomas, go to a genetic testing center for advice. Huntington's disease, a fatal neurological disorder, which is passed on genetically, runs in their family. Neither one of the men shows symptoms of the disease. This is not uncommon, however, since the average age of the onset of symptoms is the mid-30s, but frequently the mid-40s and even the mid-50s.
There is a 50 percent chance that Willy has inherited the gene for Huntington's disease, and if so, a 50 percent chance he has passed it along to his son Thomas. Willy has made a conscious choice not to be tested for the gene because he would rather live his life not knowing than suffer the consequences of such devastating news. Thomas, on the other hand, feels compelled to be tested so that he can plan his life accordingly.
. . .
Keywords: ethical issues, ethics, medical
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation