Binary Law Meets Complex Reality: The Occupation of Gaza Debate

Israel Law Review, Vol. 41, pp. 68-86, 2008

Hebrew University International Law Research Paper No. 14-08

20 Pages Posted: 5 Nov 2008

See all articles by Yuval Shany

Yuval Shany

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Faculty of Law and Institute of Criminology; Israel Democracy Institute

Date Written: November 1, 2008

Abstract

The debate surrounding the legal status of Gaza after Israel's disengagement in September 2005 exemplifies some of the chronic limits and deficiencies that international humanitarian law in general and the law of occupation in particular suffer from: (a) binary application - the law operates within clear-cut dichotomies and struggles with recognizing ambiguous situations; (b) varying realities - prevalent tensions between "legal reality" and the actual conditions "on the ground" cause the characterization of conflicts to be based upon different law-based and fact-based perceptions of reality; (c) inconsistent legal and policy approaches - parties to a conflict attempt to simultaneously advance different legal and political goals, which leads to a state of affairs that encourages the application of IHL in a selective and inconsistent manner; (d) chronic gaps between law as it is and law as it should be - lex lata may bring about unsatisfactory outcomes - hence, parties and commentators often attempt to modify existing laws through radical reinterpretations. Focusing on the recent debate over the status of Gaza, this Article illustrates how these four fundamental tensions hamper the application of the law of occupation in factually complicated situations.

Keywords: Israel, Gaza, occupation, disengagement, humanitarian law, application of IHL

Suggested Citation

Shany, Yuval, Binary Law Meets Complex Reality: The Occupation of Gaza Debate (November 1, 2008). Israel Law Review, Vol. 41, pp. 68-86, 2008, Hebrew University International Law Research Paper No. 14-08, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1293304

Yuval Shany (Contact Author)

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Faculty of Law and Institute of Criminology ( email )

Mount Scopus
Mount Scopus, IL 91905
Israel
972 2 5882541 (Phone)
972 2 5823042 (Fax)

Israel Democracy Institute ( email )

4 Pinsker St.
Jerusalem
Israel

HOME PAGE: http://www.idi.org.il

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
492
Abstract Views
2,217
Rank
106,092
PlumX Metrics