Bloomer Girl Revisited or How to Frame an Unmade Picture
Columbia Law School, Center for Law and Economic Studies, Working Paper No. 141
32 Pages Posted: 21 Oct 1998
There are 2 versions of this paper
Bloomer Girl Revisited or How to Frame an Unmade Picture
Date Written: September 1998
Abstract
The standard analysis of Parker v. Twentieth Century Fox follows the court in focusing on whether the substitute employment offered Shirley MacLaine was "different and inferior" from that which she had initially contracted for. That, this paper argues, was the wrong question. The court managed to produce the right outcome, but through convoluted reasoning that failed to recognize the essential feature of the contract. The contract had a "pay-or-play" provision by which the studio, in effect, purchased an option on her time; they would pay her to be ready to make a particular film, but they made no promise to actually use her in making the film. Cancellation did not entail breach, and, therefore, it was unnecessary to ask whether she had failed to mitigate.
The paper traces the case through the courts, showing how the attention paid the pay-or-play feature declined. It then analyzes the economics of the pay-or-play clause. The clause gives the studio an option, giving it the flexibility to adapt or to abandon a project. The pay-or-play clause is a nuanced balancing of the studio's need for flexibility against the artist's reliance.
JEL Classification: K12, L14
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Courts of Law and Unforeseen Contingencies
By Luca Anderlini, Leonardo Felli, ...
-
The Law and Economics of Costly Contracting
By Alan Schwartz and Joel Watson
-
Courts of Law and Unforeseen Contingencies
By Luca Anderlini, Leonardo Felli, ...
-
Courts of Law and Unforeseen Contingencies (Second Version)
By Leonardo Felli, Luca Anderlini, ...
-
Contract, Mechanism Design, and Technological Detail
By Joel Watson
-
Should Courts Always Enforce What Contracting Parties Write?
By Luca Anderlini, Leonardo Felli, ...
-
Should Courts Always Enforce What Contracting Parties Write?
By Luca Anderlini, Leonardo Felli, ...