EU Law 'Transformed'? Evaluating Accountability and Subsidiarity in the 'Streamlined' OMC for Social Inclusion and Social Protection
European Integration online Papers (EIoP), Special Issue 1, Vol. 13, No. 8, 2009
15 Pages Posted: 18 Feb 2010
There are 2 versions of this paper
EU Law 'Transformed'? Evaluating Accountability and Subsidiarity in the 'Streamlined' OMC for Social Inclusion and Social Protection
EU Law 'Transformed'? Evaluating Accountability and Subsidiarity in the 'Streamlined' OMC for Social Inclusion and Social Protection
Date Written: November 18, 2009
Abstract
From initially defining new governance processes as external to "traditional" forms of EU law, a number of academic scholars have begun to argue that methods like the OMC can be seen as indicative of a broader "transformation" of European law-making. The transformation thesis relies on seeing the OMC as an evolving legal mechanism, in which features such as peer review, and the participation of 'new' constitutional actors, can take the place of traditional forms of legal accountability and participation.
At the same time, the transformation thesis remains empirically under-developed. Taking the new streamlined OMC process in social inclusion and social protection as its starting point, this paper will seek to remedy that gap. The paper evaluates the transformation thesis using interview data gained from the recent Commission evaluation of the OMC SPSI (conducted from 2005-2006). While the OMC SPSI displays evidence for a number of its features – it also displays some of the limits of the 'transformation' idea.
While the OMC as it stands indicates elements of a more 'dynamic' form of accountability and subsidiarity in the EU order, its lack of critical review and transparency, and failure to include local or regional actors casts doubt on its suitability as a replacement for traditional legal accountability mechanisms. As much as 'transformation' may offer an attractive future for EU law, its dynamic vision for open coordination remains largely unrealised.
Keywords: accountability, European law, governance, legitimacy, open coordination, rule of law, social policy, subsidiarity, political science
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Construction of EU's Childcare Policy through the Open Method of Coordination
-
Governing the Knowledge Society: Studying Lisbon as Epistemic Setting
-
Learning About Policy Learning: Reflections on the European Employment Strategy
-
The Double Voluntarism in EU Social Dialogue and Employment Policy
By Armin Schäfer and Simone Leiber
-
What Kind of Consensus? Conflicting Notions of Effectiveness within the Social Protection Committee
By Anna Horvath