On the Relationship Among Partisan Effects, Electoral Probability, and Economic Uncertainty
Posted: 6 Jul 2011 Last revised: 4 Dec 2016
Date Written: July 6, 2011
Abstract
The literature on the political economy of finance suggests that government partisanship affects financial risk. Systematic risk should increase (decrease) as the chances of a Democrat (Republican) winning an election improve. At the same time, however, economic voting theories highlight that financial risk should affect vote intentions, and thus parties’ electoral prospects. We address this endogeneity problem, which has bedeviled previous work on partisanship and financial markets, by using positive Democratic campaign events as an instrument for the electoral probabilities of the Democratic presidential candidate, Barack Obama, during the 2008 presidential election. We find that a 1-percentage point increase in the probability of the Democratic candidate winning can raise systematic risk on the U.S. stock market by 0.096 percentage points (according to IV estimates). An unadjusted OLS estimation finds a 0.061-percentage points increase on average. The corrected estimates are considerably higher than estimates that do not account for reverse causality. In monetary terms, the difference approximates an average market value of about $4 billion. Thus, there exists a strong reversal effect in which economic uncertainty reduces the probability that the Democratic candidate will win an upcoming election.
Keywords: Partisan effects, U.S. presidential election, prediction markets, systematic risk, conditional and implied volatility, instrumental variable estimation
JEL Classification: P16, O16, G38
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Greek Implied Volatility Index: Construction and Properties
-
International Market Volatility Indexes: A Study on Vx1, Vdax and VIX
By Sofiane Aboura and Christophe Villa
-
The Information Content of Implied Volatility Indexes for Forecasting Volatility and Market Risk
By Pierre Giot
-
International Transmission of Volatility: A Study on the Volatility Indexes Vx1, Vdax and VIX
-
Local and Spillover Shocks in Implied Market Volatility: Evidence for the U.S. And Germany
By Alexander Szimayer and Niklas Wagner
-
International Transmission of Uncertainty Implicit in Stock Index Option Prices
By Petri Sahlström and Jussi Nikkinen
-
Implied Volatility Indices as Leading Indicators of Stock Index Returns?
By Pierre Giot
-
By Costas Milas and Ilias Lekkos
-
By Dajiang Guo