Does Set-Relational Causation Fit into a Potential Outcomes Framework? An Assessment of Gerring’s Proposal

Newsletter of the APSA Section on Qualitative Methods and Multi-Methods Research, Spring 2012

19 Pages Posted: 6 Jul 2012

See all articles by Carsten Schneider

Carsten Schneider

Central European University (CEU)

Ingo Rohlfing

Bremen International Graduate School of Social Sciences

Date Written: June 30, 2012

Abstract

One of John Gerring’s aims in his intriguing treatment of social science methodology is the development of a unified account for causal inference on the basis of the potential outcomes (PO) framework (Gerring, John (2012): Social Science Methodology: A Unified Framework. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.). Over the past two decades, the PO framework has become central in quantitative analyses. In qualitative research, in contrast, set theory and set-relational (SR) forms of causation and empirical research have started to play an ever more important role. According to Gerring, the PO account is the more general framework and is able to accommodate SR causation such as necessity and sufficiency. In our contribution to this symposium, we discuss the viability of Gerring’s proposal on how to perform SR research on the basis of the PO framework. Most importantly, we show that the suggested procedure can produce false negatives – indicating the absence of a set relation when, in fact, one exists – and false positives – suggesting the presence of a set relation when there is none. In the concluding section, we detail that if the PO and SR frameworks are truly compatible, all of these SR features must be transposed into the PO framework.

Keywords: causal inference, causation, potential outcomes, set relations

JEL Classification: C00

Suggested Citation

Schneider, Carsten and Rohlfing, Ingo, Does Set-Relational Causation Fit into a Potential Outcomes Framework? An Assessment of Gerring’s Proposal (June 30, 2012). Newsletter of the APSA Section on Qualitative Methods and Multi-Methods Research, Spring 2012, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2096834

Carsten Schneider (Contact Author)

Central European University (CEU) ( email )

Nador utca 9
Budapest, H-1051
Hungary

Ingo Rohlfing

Bremen International Graduate School of Social Sciences ( email )

Wiener Strasse
FVG-West
Bremen, DE 28215
Germany

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
99
Abstract Views
734
Rank
244,439
PlumX Metrics