Disagreement and Asset Prices
44 Pages Posted: 15 Dec 2012 Last revised: 18 May 2023
Date Written: December 2012
Abstract
How do differences of opinion affect asset prices? Do investors earn a risk premium when disagreement arises in the market? Despite their fundamental importance, these questions are among the most controversial issues in finance. In this paper, we use a novel data set that allows us to directly measure the level of disagreement among Wall Street mortgage dealers about prepayment speeds. We examine how disagreement evolves over time and study its effects on expected returns, return volatility, and trading volume in the mortgage-backed security market. We find that increased disagreement is associated with higher expected returns, higher return volatility, and larger trading volume. These results imply that there is a positive risk premium for disagreement in asset prices. We also show that volatility in and of itself does not lead to higher trading volume. Rather, it is only when disagreement arises in the market that higher uncertainty is associated with more trading. Finally, we are able to distinguish empirically between two competing hypotheses regarding how information in markets gets incorporated into asset prices. We find that sophisticated investors appear to update their beliefs through a rational expectations mechanism when disagreement arises.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
TBA Trading and Liquidity in the Agency MBS Market
By James I. Vickery and Joshua Wright
-
TBA Trading and Liquidity in the Agency MBS Market
By James I. Vickery and Joshua Wright
-
A Private Lender Cooperative Model for Residential Mortgage Finance
By Toni Dechario, Patricia C. Mosser, ...
-
By Tri Vi Dang, Gary B. Gorton, ...
-
Transparency and Liquidity in the Structured Product Market
By Nils Friewald, Rainer Jankowitsch, ...
-
Understanding Chinese Bond Yields and Their Role in Monetary Policy
By Nathan Porter and Nuno Cassola
-
The Influence of Fannie and Freddie on Mortgage Loan Terms
By Alex Kaufman
-
Transparency in the Financial System: Rollover Risk and Crises
By Matthieu Bouvard, Pierre Chaigneau, ...