Forecasting the Macroeconomy: Analysts versus Economists
48 Pages Posted: 28 Dec 2012
Date Written: December 27, 2012
Abstract
We investigate whether and to what extent aggregate earnings forecasts by sell-side analysts and forecasts of macroeconomic indicators by economists convey different information about the macroeconomy, and whether such differences have implications for forecast efficiency and the stock market. We find that the two sets of forecasts strongly covary over the 1984 to 2010 period, suggesting that they contain a non-trivial amount of common macroeconomic information. We also find that while real GDP growth forecasts have incremental predictive ability over aggregate earnings forecasts with respect to future aggregate earnings, the converse is not true. Additional tests suggest that analysts underreact to economists’ negative forecast revisions (i.e., aggregate earnings forecast errors are predictably more negative following economists’ downward forecast revisions), with the extent of underreaction more pronounced for more procyclical and larger firms. The stock market does not appear to see through such inefficiency — the market returns surrounding the first few “bellwether” firms’ earnings announcements are predictably more negative following quarters with more negative macroeconomic forecast revisions. Finally, we show that an “adjusted” aggregate earnings forecast that incorporates macroeconomic forecast revisions performs marginally better in terms of forecast accuracy and efficiency.
Keywords: Macroeconomy, earnings, economists, financial analysts, inefficiency
JEL Classification: E37, E44, G17, G24, M41
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Stock Returns, Aggregate Earnings Surprises, and Behavioral Finance
By Jonathan Lewellen, S.p. Kothari, ...
-
Accruals and Aggregate Stock Market Returns
By David A. Hirshleifer, Kewei Hou, ...
-
Predictability and the Earnings-Returns Relation
By Gil Sadka and Ronnie Sadka
-
Predictability and the Earnings-Returns Relation
By Gil Sadka and Ronnie Sadka
-
Predicting Stock Market Returns with Aggregate Discretionary Accruals
By Qiang Kang, Qiao Liu, ...
-
Predicting Stock Market Returns with Aggregate Discretionary Accruals
By Qiang Kang, Qiao Liu, ...