Hidden Efficiencies: On the Relevance of Business Justifications in Abuse of Dominance Cases
40 Pages Posted: 12 Sep 2013
Date Written: September 10, 2013
Abstract
This article assesses the relevance of efficiencies and other justifications in recent Article 102 TFEU cases. Based on a review of all EU decisions and openings between 2009 and mid 2013 we find that procompetitive justifications still play a mediocre role in the EU Commission’s evaluations, except in IT related abuse cases. This stands in contrast to the policy goals expressed during the reform phase (2005 to 2009), the Guidance Paper and the increasing relevance of efficiency considerations in merger proceedings. We argue that this is due to a malfunctioning of the balancing test, i.e., the weighting of pro- and anticompetitive effects, as pro- and anticompetitive effects are often non-separable and non-monotone in Article 102 TFEU cases. In addition, the increasing practice of commitment decisions reduces transparency; little guidance regarding dynamic efficiencies further diminishes the relevance of business justifications in Article 102 TFEU cases. Policy options are discussed.
Keywords: European competition policy, abuse of dominance, efficiency defense
JEL Classification: K21, L21, L40
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Unilateral Competitive Effects of Horizontal Mergers
By Gregory J. Werden and Luke M. Froeb
-
Post-Merger Product Repositioning
By Amit Kumar Gandhi, Luke M. Froeb, ...
-
Pass-Through Rates and the Price Effects of Mergers
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tschantz, ...
-
Mergers when Firms Compete by Choosing both Price and Promotion
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tenn, ...
-
Calibrated Economic Models Add Focus, Accuracy, and Persuasiveness to Merger Analysis
By Gregory J. Werden and Luke M. Froeb
-
Merger Simulation with Brand-Level Margin: Extending Pcaids with Nests
-
Vertical Restraints and the Effects of Upstream Horizontal Mergers
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tschantz, ...
-
Efficiency Considerations in Merger Enforcement
By Robert H. Lande and Alan A. Fisher
-
Quantifying the Scope for Efficiency Defense in Merger Control: The Werden-Froeb-Index