The Science of Sentencing: Measurement Theory and Von Hirsch's New Scales of Justice
Sentencing & Society: International Perspectives, C. Tata & N. Hutton, eds., Ashgate, 2002
32 Pages Posted: 6 Dec 2013
Date Written: December 4, 2002
Abstract
Andrew von Hirsch has been a leader in the movement towards establishing proportionality in sentencing since the revival of interest in just deserts began in the 1970s. His sentencing model, which has been developed in the public arena over a period of more than 20 years, contains detailed philosophical justifications for state punishment and is supported by specific practical proposals for constructing a sentencing system. No doubt because of these three features, von Hirsch's ideas have attracted much attention and comment. Not all of it however, is positive. This paper focuses on von Hirsch's model and its critics and uses the theory of measurement as a source of critique instead of the more usual choice of the philosophy of punishment.
Keywords: sentencing, state punishment
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation