After the Override: An Empirical Analysis of Shadow Precedent

58 Pages Posted: 22 Jul 2014 Last revised: 14 Jun 2017

See all articles by Brian J. Broughman

Brian J. Broughman

Vanderbilt University Law School

Deborah A. Widiss

Indiana University Maurer School of Law

Multiple version iconThere are 2 versions of this paper

Date Written: January 1, 2017

Abstract

Congressional overrides of prior judicial interpretations of statutory language are typically defined as equivalent to judicial overrulings, and they are presumed to play a central role in maintaining legislative supremacy. Our study is the first to empirically test these assumptions. Using a differences-in-differences research design, we find that citation levels decrease far less after legislative overrides than after judicial overrulings. This pattern holds true even when controlling for depth of the superseding event or considering only the specific proposition that was superseded. Moreover, contrary to what one might expect, citation levels decrease more quickly after restorative overrides—in which Congress repudiates the prior Supreme Court decision as incorrect—than after overrides intended to update or clarify the law. This suggests that ongoing citation of overridden precedents, what we call shadow precedents, may be driven more by information failure or ambiguity than by ideological disagreements between the branches of government.

Keywords: overrides; precedent; citation patterns; separation-of-powers; legislative supremacy

JEL Classification: K10

Suggested Citation

Broughman, Brian J. and Widiss, Deborah A., After the Override: An Empirical Analysis of Shadow Precedent (January 1, 2017). Indiana Legal Studies Research Paper No. 312, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2470278 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2470278

Brian J. Broughman

Vanderbilt University Law School ( email )

131 21st Avenue South
Nashville, TN 37203-1181
United States

Deborah A. Widiss (Contact Author)

Indiana University Maurer School of Law ( email )

211 S. Indiana Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47405
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
96
Abstract Views
1,304
Rank
247,469
PlumX Metrics