Human Rights & Environment in Investment Arbitration: A Tale of Two Wars and Two Battles (Aguas V Argentina; Glamis Gold V. USA)

17 Pages Posted: 31 Oct 2017

See all articles by Garv Malhotra

Garv Malhotra

National University of Singapore (NUS), Faculty of Law, Students ; Skywards Law

Date Written: October 29, 2017

Abstract

Human rights and environment are those two chapters seldom found in most treaties and treatise on international investment law. Most investment tribunals prefer to skilfully skirt the issues with the apprehension of developing the law one way or the other or over-stepping their mandate. They represent two issues which have historically, and will perhaps in future, symbolize ‘bones of contention’.

This 'tug-of-war' has been repeatedly fought between states inter se across negotiation tables and between states and investors in arbitral proceedings. History has shown that some, though not all, international corporations have blatantly disregarded human rights and the host state's environment. Instances like 'Bhopal gas tragedy' and 'Lempa river' fiasco may have faded in the memory of the international community but have forever scarred the victims. But this is a cyclic debate, for foreign investors come to developing countries to do what they cannot in their own. Thus, the competing interests have to be balanced to ensure sustainability.

This article discusses the controversies surrounding Human Rights and Environment in Investment Arbitration from the perspective of 2 leading caselaw 1. Suez, Sociedad General de Aguas de Barcelona, S.A. and Vivendi Universal, S.A. v. Argentine Republic, ICSID Case No. ARB/03/19 and Glamis Gold, Ltd v United States of America, Award of 8 June 2009, [2009] 48 ILM 1039 (International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes).

Keywords: Investment Arbitration, Human Rights, Environment, Investment Law, Aguas, Vivendi, Suez, Argentina, Glamis Gold, ISDS, ISA, ICSID, NAFTA, Investment, Arbitration

Suggested Citation

Malhotra, Garv and Malhotra, Garv, Human Rights & Environment in Investment Arbitration: A Tale of Two Wars and Two Battles (Aguas V Argentina; Glamis Gold V. USA) (October 29, 2017). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3061638 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3061638

Garv Malhotra (Contact Author)

Skywards Law ( email )

E#502, SANMATI TOWERS, SECTOR 6,
PLOT 19A, DWARKA
NEW DELHI, 110075
India
09717503706 (Phone)
110075 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.skywardslaw.com

National University of Singapore (NUS), Faculty of Law, Students ( email )

Singapore

0 References

    0 Citations

      Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

      Paper statistics

      Downloads
      188
      Abstract Views
      751
      Rank
      332,068
      PlumX Metrics