Why is There an Anti-Trade Bias in Trade Policy?
University of Maryland Center for International Economics Working Paper No. 02-03
41 Pages Posted: 3 Apr 2003
Date Written: December 2002
Abstract
Small economies rarely embrace free trade, a fact that is commonly explained as a consequence of the government's use of trade policy to redistribute income. But why is this redistribution typically biased in favor of import-competing sectors and is consequently trade restricting rather than trade promoting? This remains an important puzzle in trade policy. Most models assume the puzzle away by restricting the government set of policies or else generate the opposite, and empirically counterfactual, prediction--that trade policy has a pro-trade bias (e.g. Grossman-Helpman AER 1994). We show that if the government's objective reflects a concern for inequality, or diminishing marginal political support from factor owners, then trade policy exhibits anti-trade bias. Importantly the mechanism that we analyze generates the anti-trade bias independently of whether factors are specific or mobile across sectors. The mechanism also generates an anti-trade bias between large countries even after they sign reciprocal trade agreements that eliminate any terms-of-trade motivation for the use of trade protection.
Keywords: trade policy, inequality, anti-trade bias
JEL Classification: F13
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Protection for Sale: An Empirical Investigation
By Pinelopi Goldberg and Giovanni Maggi
-
Protection for Sale and Trade Liberalization: An Empirical Investigation
-
Protection for Sale: An Empirical Investigation: Comment
By Theo S. Eicher and Thomas Osang
-
Foreign Lobbies and Us Trade Policy
By Kishore Gawande, Pravin Krishna, ...
-
Do Labor Issues Matter in the Determination of U.S. Trade Policy? An Empirical Reevaluation
By Xenia Matschke and Shane M. Sherlund
-
Lobbying Competition Over Trade Policy
By Kishore Gawande, Pravin Krishna, ...
-
Lobbying Competition Over Trade Policy
By Kishore Gawande, Pravin Krishna, ...