Some Doubts About Argument by Hypothetical

15 Pages Posted: 7 Feb 2005

See all articles by Paul H. Robinson

Paul H. Robinson

University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School

Abstract

In his paper, Why the Successful Assassin Is More Wicked than the Unsuccessful One, Leo Katz pick[s] up the gauntlet [Sandy] Kadish throws down to offer a nonconsequentialist justification for giving significance to resulting harm and, in particular, to justify the common practice of punishing attempts less than the completed offense.

In one sense, I may not be the ideal person to serve as critic. I am not one of those who, like Kadish and others, does not believe in the significance of resulting harm in assessing blameworthiness (people whom Katz calls the luck-skeptics but to whom I will refer as the nonbelievers in the significance of resulting harm). I will try to perform the mental gymnastics of pretending to be a nonbeliever as I evaluate Professor Katz's arguments. As Part I explains, I fear the nonbeliever will be unpersuaded.

Whatever the outcome of the debate as Professor Katz presents it, the method of his argument raises issues that I think are just as interesting as its outcome. My social science work, as limited as it is, gives me pause when assessing the argument-by-hypothetical method that Professor Katz uses so ingeniously here (and elsewhere). Relatedly, I have some doubts about using our intuitions in the way Professor Katz would have us use them here (and elsewhere), or at least doubts about whether we can draw from them the kind of conclusions about moral desert that Professor Katz would have us draw.

Setting aside these two concerns for a moment, let me consider Professor Katz's arguments on their own terms.

Keywords: Moral desert, desert, punishment

JEL Classification: K14

Suggested Citation

Robinson, Paul H., Some Doubts About Argument by Hypothetical. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=662061

Paul H. Robinson (Contact Author)

University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School ( email )

3501 Sansom Street
Philadelphia, PA 19104
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
112
Abstract Views
1,960
Rank
441,967
PlumX Metrics