Safety Nets or Social Insurance in the Presence of Poverty Traps? Evidence from Southern Ethiopia
50 Pages Posted: 3 May 2005
Date Written: April 2005
Abstract
Recent empirical work finds evidence of highly nonlinear wealth dynamics among the Boran pastoralists of southern Ethiopia, consistent with the hypothesis of poverty traps. We ask two critical, logically subsequent questions: (1) Do Boran pastoralists understand these dynamics? (2) If they do, what are the consequences for informal interhousehold transfers arrangements (gifts and loans of cattle)? We address these questions using original primary data collected among the same population to establish (i) pastoralists' expectations of herd dynamics and (ii) the structure of social transfers networks. Our results suggest that Borana pastoralists perceive the nonlinear dynamics that characterize livestock wealth in the region and that these result from adverse weather shocks affecting primarily households of intermediate herding ability, underscoring the criticality of methods for protecting assets in the face of unanticipated shocks. This has consequences on the design of transfer arrangements. In particular, we find that transfers of cattle respond to recipients' cattle losses, but only so long as he does not fall too far below the critical asset threshold at which herd dynamics bifurcate. Those who are persistently poor or who become destitute disappear from social networks and do not receive transfers in response to shocks. The resulting social transfers networks are highly asymmetric. These results suggest that asset transfers through social networks are better conceptualized as part of a safety net (with the objective of not letting a household falling into an asset poverty trap) than as informal mutual insurance (with the objective of providing proportional compensation for losses).
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Stochastic Wealth Dynamics and Risk Management Among a Poor Population
By Travis J. Lybbert, Christopher B. Barrett, ...
-
Social Identity and Manipulative Interhousehold Transfers Among East African Pastoralists
-
Not Necessarily in the Same Boat: Heterogeneous Risk Assessment Among East African Pastoralists
By Kevin Smith, Christopher B. Barrett, ...
-
Household Income Dynamics in Rural China
By Martin Ravallion and Jyotsna Jalan
-
Heterogeneous Wealth Dynamics: On the Roles of Risk and Ability
-
Bayesian Herders: Asymmetric Updating of Rainfall Beliefs in Response to External Forecasts
By Travis J. Lybbert, Christopher B. Barrett, ...
-
Bayesian Herders: Optimistic Updating of Rainfall Beliefs in Response to External Forecasts
By Travis J. Lybbert, Christopher B. Barrett, ...
-
Occupational Choice and Dynamic Incentives
By Maitreesh Ghatak, Massimo Morelli, ...