Services, Citizenship, and the Country of Origin Principle
Mitchell Working Paper No. 2/2007
24 Pages Posted: 20 Aug 2007
Abstract
The country of origin principle requires states to apply different legal regimes to companies and persons according to their state of origin. This looks rather like nationality discrimination, contrary to Article 12 EC. It is also fundamentally at odds with one of the central pillars of citizenship, both national and European; equality between citizens. The preference for a relatively unfettered country of origin principle in the Services Directive raises doubts whether the directive has an adequate legal basis, and in any case makes it undesirable. It is an example of economic law that has profound impacts on many non-economic aspects of life. It fragments jurisdictions, and therefore societies. Yet it has been made with only the narrowest of trade interests in mind. It shows the danger of allowing technocracy-led legislation. And nor are the economic arguments even good. If Member States cannot apply their law within their jurisdiction, then their capacity to develop coherent regulatory regimes is undermined, and the competition between these regimes which might revitalise national legislation, to the benefit of economic and non-economic life, cannot take place. The degree of openness of markets is only one part of wealth creation, and so should be part of regulatory competition, not a precondition for it.
Keywords: citizenship, country of origin, services, services directive, european union, european law, discrimination, regulatory competition
JEL Classification: K00, K19, K23, K20, K33
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Gay Rights in the EU: A Long Way Forward for the Union of 27
-
Citizenship as Inherited Property
By Ayelet Shachar and Ran Hirschl
-
Constitutional Disagreement in Europe and the Search for Pluralism
-
The Case of Laval in the Context of the Post-Enlargement EC Law Development
-
Europeanisation of Citizenship within the EU: Perspectives and Ambiguities
-
Proportionality and the Culture of Justification
By Moshe Cohen-eliya and Iddo Porat
-
Citizenship without Respect: The EU's Troubled Equality Ideal