Mutual Misunderstanding in Contract
42 Pages Posted: 11 Jun 2008 Last revised: 7 Dec 2009
Date Written: 2009
Abstract
It is accepted throughout the common law that agreements founded on a mutual misunderstanding are void ab initio. It follows from this that unenforcement is necessary and inevitable; indeed, there is simply no contract to enforce. Curiously, however, in cases involving mutual misunderstanding the parties themselves usually believe and behave as if they have settled upon a knowable and enforceable agreement from the outset. It is typically only sometime later that the mutual misunderstanding between the parties comes to light. In this article I question the wisdom of the widely accepted common law rule surrounding mutual misunderstanding. I present and defend an alternative legal rule that significantly improves upon the efficiency of the results in cases involving mutual misunderstanding. The rule I propose would allow each party to an agreement founded on mutual misunderstanding to have the option to enforce his or her reasonable understanding of the agreement vis-a-vis the other party. This rule can be shown to preserve the reasonable expectations of the parties, promote reliance on promises, and provide implicit insurance against the risk that a mutual misunderstanding will interfere with the realization of expected contractual surplus.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Common Law Disclosure Duties and the Sin of Omission: Testing the Meta-Theories
-
Defective Products and Fraud and Misrepresentation Claims in Minnesota
-
Law and Economics of Fraudulent Misrepresentation
By Qi Zhou
-
Trust, Power (A)Symmetry and Misrepresentation in Negotiation
By Mara Olekalns and Philip Smith
-
Economic Analysis of the Legal Standard of Deceit in English Law
By Qi Zhou
-
New Rules for Promissory Fraud
By Ian Ayres and Gregory Klass
-
Asymmetric Information in Consumer Contracts: The Challenge that is Yet to be Met
-
By Qi Zhou