Reciprocity, Exchange and Redistribution: An Experimental Investigation Inspired by Karl Polanyi's 'The Economy as Instituted Process'
21 Pages Posted: 2 Jul 2008
Date Written: June 28, 2008
Abstract
Inspired by Karl Polanyi's writings on three allocation modes, namely reciprocity, exchange and redistribution, we first tested a reciprocity ring with ten players. The baseline treatment, with no possibility of socialisation, displayed very low levels of allocative efficiency. Consistently with the Polanyian approach to reciprocity, we found that inducing the notion of symmetry among the players increased efficiency levels significantly. We then simulated a market exchange, with significant allocative efficiency gains. We conclude that indirect-reciprocity rings among anonymous players can seldom function in the absence of definite institutional refinements, promoting forms of symmetry-acknowledgement.
Keywords: Reciprocity, Redistribution, Exchange, Comparative Institutional Analysis
JEL Classification: Z13, D02, C91
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation