Stigma, Ethics and Policy: A Response to Bayer
Social Science & Medicine, Vol. 67, p. 473, 2008
11 Pages Posted: 24 Jul 2008 Last revised: 17 Sep 2008
Date Written: July 23, 2008
Abstract
In Stigma and the Ethics of Public Health: Not Can We but Should We, 67 SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2008), Ronald Bayer asks whether "stigmatization always represents a threat to public health?" and whether "there [are] occasions when the mobilization of stigma may effectively reduce the prevalence of behaviors linked to disease and death?" In this commentary, I offer an unambiguous answer: Yes, and No. For purposes of an ethical analysis of stigma in public health practice, we should ignore Erving Goffman's treatment of stigma as a universal phenomenon. We should instead start with his account of how stigma works, and follow scholars like Bruce Link and Jo Phelan in trying to understand stigma as a harmful phenomenon experienced by vulnerable groups. It remains unclear that smokers, the group Bayer chooses as is example, are stigmatized in that sort of framework. If they are, the state and those working under its auspices should not be promoting or indulging that stigma in any way, because stigma is a barbaric form of social control that relies upon the most primitive and destructive of emotions. And chances are it won't work anyway.
Keywords: Public Health, Ethics, Shaming, tobacco
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Law and the Public's Health: A Study of Infectious Disease Law in the United States
By Lawrence O. Gostin, Scott Burris, ...
-
The Invisibility of Public Health: Population-Level Measures in a Politics of Market Individualism
By Scott Burris
-
Surveillance, Social Risk, and Symbolism: Framing the Analysis for Research and Policy
By Scott Burris
-
Disease Stigma in U.S. Public Health Law
By Scott Burris
-
Public Health, 'Aids Exceptionalism' and the Law
By Scott Burris
-
Patients and Providers in the Courts: Fractures in the Americans with Disabilities Act
-
Emerging Issues in Chinese Health Law
By Scott Burris and Shen Weixing
-
The Impact of HIV/AIDS on the Development of Public Health Law
By Scott Burris and Lawrence O. Gostin