States and Pre-State Actors: The Nomadic Challenge to Westphalian Territoriality

44 Pages Posted: 13 Aug 2009 Last revised: 25 Aug 2009

See all articles by Joseph MacKay

Joseph MacKay

University of Toronto

Gustavo S. de Carvalho

University of Toronto - Department of Political Science

Kristin T. Cavoukian

University of Toronto - Department of Political Science

Ross Cuthbert

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Jamie Levin

University of Toronto - International Relations; Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Date Written: 2009

Abstract

The collapse of walls and borders after the Cold War has been coupled with a proliferation of transborder non-state actors. However, many non-state actors predate the state system itself. Surveying the phenomenon of traditional nomadism, this paper seeks to extend a critical dialogue about territoriality and borders in IR. Nomadism appears to present unique challenges to sovereignty. It destabilizes the state’s ability to maintain a territorially fixed population under law, undermining the state’s ability to control its borders. Adopting a constructivist approach, we argue that nomadism constitutes as much an ideational as a material threat to the state. The impulse to delegitimate and curtail nomadism belongs to the ideational structure of sovereignty. By disrupting the territorial foundation of statehood, nomadism becomes a source of ontological insecurity for the state.

States have responded to nomadism chiefly in three ways. Many forcibly settle nomads. Others facilitate relatively free international migration, by reducing the salience of borders as barriers to transit. In many further instances, weak states are unable to secure borders, allowing nomads to migrate relatively freely. We offer three examples: Bedouins, often forcibly settled; Roma, permitted to migrate transnationally within the European Union; and African pastoralists, permitted to migrate by porous borders. While the Bedouin and African instances suggest a necessary conflict between the role of state and the culture of nomadism, the European experience suggests that an ontological desecuritization of nomadism is possible: a relaxation of borders can allow these two political frames of reference to coexist.

Suggested Citation

MacKay, Joseph and de Carvalho, Gustavo S. and Cavoukian, Kristin T. and Cuthbert, Ross and Levin, Jamie and Levin, Jamie, States and Pre-State Actors: The Nomadic Challenge to Westphalian Territoriality (2009). APSA 2009 Toronto Meeting Paper, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1449352

Joseph MacKay (Contact Author)

University of Toronto ( email )

Gustavo S. De Carvalho

University of Toronto - Department of Political Science ( email )

Sidney Smith Hall
100 St George Street
Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G3
Canada

Kristin T. Cavoukian

University of Toronto - Department of Political Science ( email )

Sidney Smith Hall
100 St George Street
Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G3
Canada

Ross Cuthbert

affiliation not provided to SSRN

No Address Available

Jamie Levin

University of Toronto - International Relations ( email )

Toronto
Canada

Hebrew University of Jerusalem ( email )

Mount Scopus
Jerusalem, Jerusalem 91905
Israel

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
229
Abstract Views
1,317
Rank
242,334
PlumX Metrics