Superior Responsibility of Civilians for International Crimes Committed in Civilian Settings
Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, Vol. 43, No. 2, 2010
Hebrew University International Law Research Paper No. 16-09
39 Pages Posted: 22 Aug 2009 Last revised: 15 Apr 2015
Date Written: August 20, 2009
Abstract
The article examines the notion of superior responsibility of civilians for international crimes committed in civilian settings. The doctrine of superior responsibility grew out of the military doctrine of command responsibility, and its evolution is informed by this origin. Jurisprudence and academic writers emphasize that the doctrine is also applicable to civilian superiors, but the discourse has invariably focused on civilian leaders of military or paramilitary organizations. Moreover, there has never been a detailed analysis of the doctrine’s relevance and applicability in civilian settings. The article argues that the claim that superior responsibility extends to civilians, and moreover to civilian settings, is inaccurate as a matter of a customary law. In judicial practice (including recent rulings), civilians have rarely been convicted under the doctrine even as leaders of military organizations, and when they have, this conviction was generally secondary to their direct responsibility. The article elaborates various challenges to the application of the doctrine in civilian settings, particularly in the determination of the existence of a superior-subordinate relationship. Despite the difficulties in transposing the doctrine to the civilian sphere, the article argues that as a matter of policy civilians should also be subject to the doctrine. It also argues that the normative distinctions between civilians and military superiors, today entrenched in Article 28 of the ICC Statute, is neither absolutely necessary nor practicable.
Keywords: superior responsibility, command responsibility, international criminal law, ICC, ICTY, ICTR, media case, Nahimana
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Rules and Standards in the Application of International Humanitarian Law
-
Modern Military Necessity: The Role and Relevance of Military Lawyers
-
Avoid or Compensate? Liability for Incidental Injury to Civilians Inflicted During Armed Conflict
By Yael Ronen
-
The Principle of Proportionality in the Context of Operation Cast Lead: Institutional Perspectives
-
The Unique Position of National Human Rights Institutions: A Mixed Blessing?
By Anne Smith
-
Military Lawyers on the Battlefield: An Empirical Account of International Law Compliance
-
Investigating Violations of International Law in Armed Conflict
-
By Amichai Cohen and Yuval Shany