Democracy with Adjectives: Conceptual Innovation in Comparative Research
World Politics, Vol. 49, pp. 430-451, April 1997
23 Pages Posted: 25 Jan 2010 Last revised: 25 Mar 2016
Date Written: April 1, 1997
Abstract
The recent trend toward democratization in countries across the globe has challenged scholars to pursue two potentially contradictory goals. On the one hand, they seek to increase analytic differentiation in order to capture the diverse forms of democracy that have emerged. On the other hand, they are concerned with conceptual validity. Specifically, they seek to avoid the problem of conceptual stretching that arises when the concept of democracy is applied to cases for which, by relevant scholarly standards, it is not appropriate. This article argues that the pursuit of these two goals has led to a proliferation of conceptual innovations, including numerous subtypes of democracy – that is to say, democracy "with adjectives." The articles explores the strengths and weaknesses of alternative strategies of conceptual innovation that have emerged: descending and climbing Sartori's ladder of generality, generating "diminished" subtypes of democracy, "precising" the definition of democracy by adding defining attributes, and shifting the overarching concept with which democracy is associated. The goal of the analysis is to make more comprehensible the complex structure of these strategies, as well as to explore trade-offs among the strategies. Even when scholars proceed intuitively, rather than self-consciously, they tend to operate within this structure. Yet it is far more desirable for them to do so self-consciously, with a full awareness of these trade-offs.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Neopatrimonialism Revisited: Beyond a Catch-All Concept
By Gero Erdmann and Ulf Engel
-
Institutions, Inequality and Illusion in the Choice for Fair Elections
By Nancy Bermeo
-
Managing Public Outrage: Power, Scandal, and New Media in Contemporary Russia
-
A Start for Mild Liberalization? Building Civil Society Through Co-operative Dynamics in China
By Li Zhao
-
Ombudsman Autonomy, Informal Institutions and the Defense of Women's Rights in the Central Andes
-
Lingering Authoritarian Attitudes in Latin America: The Support for Caudillo Rule