The Applicability of the Energy Charter Treaty in ICSID Arbitration of EU Nationals vs. EU Member States

26 Pages Posted: 15 Jun 2010

See all articles by Christian Tietje

Christian Tietje

Martin-Luther-University - Transnational Economic Law Research Centre

Date Written: September 1, 2008

Abstract

The relationship between EC law and international investment law has gained increasing attention. This is due to ongoing proceedings before the European Court of Justice (ECJ) concerning the compatibility of bilateral investment treaties (BITs) of EU Member States with EC law, several arbitral proceedings of investors versus EU Member States based on BITs between EU Member States and/or concerning substantive legal problems that are somehow related to EC law (e.g. Eastern Sugar). Insufficient attention, however, has so far been paid to the relationship between EC law and the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) with regard to the specific situation of a possible arbitral proceeding of an EU national versus an EU Member State. As the ECT is a plurilateral treaty that has been concluded as a so-called mixed agreement by the EC and all its Member States, the questions that arise are to a large extent different than in the Eastern Sugar/BIT situation.

Accordingly this paper discusses the applicability of the ECT in ICSID arbitrations of EU nationals versus EU Member States. The first part of the paper provides an introduction to the applicable law concerning the admissibility and merits of ECT/ICSID proceedings. The second part discusses the public international status of the ECT towards the EC and its Member States and analyses the legal phenomenon of ‘mixed agreements’ within the EC and its Member States. The author continues to examine the general aspects concerning the legally-binding effects of mixed agreements such as the ECT from a public international law perspective. Following the emphasis upon a number of intrinsic legal principles of public international law, the author argues that the ECT as a mixed agreement under EC law does not influence the comprehensive legally-binding effect of the ECT treaty in view of the EC and its Member States under public international law. In the third part of the paper the contributor adheres to providing an overview of the exemptions to the comprehensive binding effects regarding mixed agreements, focussing particularly on the analysis of possible limitations of the legally-binding inter se relationship as a result of explicit and implicit ECT standards. Subsequently an intermediate conclusion is presented, which underlines that from a public international law perspective, an inter se modification of the ECT by EC law is not possible. The author continues to contextualise Part III and V of the ECT and concludes that no competency is given therein to the EC. In the last part of the paper the contributor assesses the associated sub problem of the conflicting jurisdiction in the sense of Art. 292 EC and discusses the irrelevance of Art. 307 EC from an international public law perspective in relation to ECT/ICSID proceedings.The paper closes by providing an analysis of the legal principles of lex arbitri and ordre public concerning the applicability of EC law in an ECT/ICSID proceeding. The author concludes that the legal provisions of the ECT are applicable in an ICSID proceeding of an EU national versus an EU Member State; similarly it is established that EC law does not influence such proceedings which are exclusively governed by public international law.

Suggested Citation

Tietje, Christian, The Applicability of the Energy Charter Treaty in ICSID Arbitration of EU Nationals vs. EU Member States (September 1, 2008). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1625323 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1625323

Christian Tietje (Contact Author)

Martin-Luther-University - Transnational Economic Law Research Centre ( email )

Emil-Abderhalden-Str. 7
Halle an der Saale
Berlin 06099, Sachsen-Anhalt
Germany

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
690
Abstract Views
3,294
Rank
69,413
PlumX Metrics