The Doctrine of Substantive Equality and the Democratisation of Diversities

FROM CONFLICT TO RECOGNITION: MOVING MULTICULTURALISM FORWARD, M. Kearney, ed., Forthcoming

Posted: 22 Sep 2010

See all articles by Puja Kapai

Puja Kapai

University of Hong Kong - Faculty of Law; University of Hong Kong - Centre for Comparative and Public Law

Date Written: July 1, 2010

Abstract

The coexistence of cultural and religious minorities in liberal democratic systems presents various challenges given the complexities that inhere in the just management of a diverse populace. Minorities living in these communities suffer unequal outcomes, hardships and exclusion on various accounts. This is particularly so where the equal application of the law to all individuals results in injustice when minority needs remain unaccounted for. These circumstances have forced a critical review of the institutional mechanisms which accompany governance and the visions of justice they support. Various theories have been developed to accommodate multiculturalism and address these complexities. Liberal theorists have sought to predicate rights on the core principles of the common good and individual autonomy whilst others have debated the liberal’s dilemma. Theorists of multiculturalism have offered a communitarian critique to liberalism, suggesting variegated group rights and models of accommodation. Others, however, have pointed to the critical failures of multiculturalism.

This paper critiques some of the recent developments in discourse on accommodative mechanisms, citizenship theory and minority rights. Given the failings of existing models, it argues that deliberative mechanisms customised by the doctrine of substantive equality are better able to provide an inclusive and just political framework. The doctrine of substantive equality serves to account for the gaps in existing democratic and citizenship theories. It is an indispensable tool in just government given the state of identity politics, the history of oppression, imperialism and other marginalizations experienced by minority communities. Implementing the doctrine in the deliberative context would go a long way towards fostering minority participation and inculcating civic responsibility to create a new vision for citizenship and the dispensation of justice. The paper concludes with a call for a renewed political discourse to eliminate obstacles to a consensus-building model of democratic deliberation that caters to multiculturalism and diversity.

Keywords: Multiculturalism, deliberative democracy, citizenship, substantive equality, minority rights

Suggested Citation

Kapai, Puja, The Doctrine of Substantive Equality and the Democratisation of Diversities (July 1, 2010). FROM CONFLICT TO RECOGNITION: MOVING MULTICULTURALISM FORWARD, M. Kearney, ed., Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1680204

Puja Kapai (Contact Author)

University of Hong Kong - Faculty of Law ( email )

Pokfulam Road
Hong Kong, Hong Kong
China

HOME PAGE: http://www.hku.hk/law/faculty/staff/puja_kapai_intro.html

University of Hong Kong - Centre for Comparative and Public Law ( email )

University of Hong Kong
Pokfulam Road
Pokfulam
Hong Kong

HOME PAGE: http://www.hku.hk/law/faculty/staff/puja_kapai_intro.html

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
942
PlumX Metrics