Building Inclusive and Just Societies: The Role of Deliberative Theory

Asian Legal Institute Working Paper Series No. 2010

26 Pages Posted: 27 Sep 2010 Last revised: 27 Feb 2011

See all articles by Puja Kapai

Puja Kapai

University of Hong Kong - Faculty of Law; University of Hong Kong - Centre for Comparative and Public Law

Date Written: September 27, 2010

Abstract

This paper starts from the premise that the nation-state model which enables nationals to participate in their own governance is an outdated model of political organisation in an age where plurinational states have become the norm. Drawing on the works of several political theorists who have sought to reconcile the status and role of cultural and national minorities in these states using liberal accommodation, tolerance, integration or multicultural accommodation and self-governance, this paper questions the central bases of the theories advanced.

The paper argues that citizenship needs to be reconstrued to include everyone as having an equal and reciprocal duty in their own governance, including minorities. The current failure of the nation state model which has served to entrench differences and exclusion is attributable to the limited perception of immigrant and ethnic minorities as mere subjects of the polity. This view of immigrant and ethnic minority people as passive subjects as opposed to active and interactive members of the polity, distorts their role in the political apparatus of the state, ignoring their concerns, interests and capacities for political agency. In arguing that the inclusion of these groups into the state’s political structure and in the development of law and policy would serve numerous purposes, the paper draws on various theories of justice.

The fundamental premise for such inclusion is that belonging and loyalty are cultivated through processes that require regular engagement with other groups, including minorities, in deliberative decision-making processes. Through the creation of a space for inter- and intra-group dialogue, the development of a national political identity whilst enabling the maintenance of subjective community identities becomes possible.The inclusion of minority groups in this process can help cultivate feelings of membership, commonality of purpose and ultimately, trust. In time, this trust can be capitalized upon to achieve justice through inclusion. Deliberation theory, it is argued, has an important and indispensable role in building just and inclusive societies, particularly multicultural polities.

Keywords: Inclusion, Deliberative Decision-Making, Justice, Circle of Loyalty, Participation, Substantive Equality

Suggested Citation

Kapai, Puja, Building Inclusive and Just Societies: The Role of Deliberative Theory (September 27, 2010). Asian Legal Institute Working Paper Series No. 2010, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1683776

Puja Kapai (Contact Author)

University of Hong Kong - Faculty of Law ( email )

Pokfulam Road
Hong Kong, Hong Kong
China

HOME PAGE: http://www.hku.hk/law/faculty/staff/puja_kapai_intro.html

University of Hong Kong - Centre for Comparative and Public Law ( email )

University of Hong Kong
Pokfulam Road
Pokfulam
Hong Kong

HOME PAGE: http://www.hku.hk/law/faculty/staff/puja_kapai_intro.html

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
54
Abstract Views
299
Rank
676,215
PlumX Metrics