Loan Loss Provisioning and Differences of Opinion
53 Pages Posted: 19 Oct 2011
Date Written: October 1, 2011
Abstract
Prior research suggests that differences of opinion of professional forecasters are indicative of risk and uncertainty. This study investigates whether different attributes of loan loss provisions influence the likelihood and magnitude of disagreement between the two major credit rating agencies. Focusing on a sample of bank issues from 1994 to 2009, I find that Moody’s and S&P disagree on the initial ratings of 66% of the issues and that S&P is the more conservative rater who gives a lower rating 89% of the time when there is a disagreement. I also find that S&P is more likely to give a lower rating during periods of higher economic uncertainty. In addition, I hypothesize and find that lower timeliness and validity of loan loss provisions exacerbate the likelihood and magnitude of initial credit rating splits between the two major credit rating agencies. Furthermore, discretionary loan loss provisions are positively associated with the likelihood and degree of differences of opinion. Finally, I find bank bondholders demand a yield premium on split rated bonds. The findings in this paper suggest that accounting information quality influences the perceived risks and uncertainties in banking industry and is useful in facilitating bondholders’ market discipline of banks’ risk exposures.
Keywords: Rating disagreement, Loan loss provisions, Accounting quality, Rating agency, Banking
JEL Classification: G21, G24, G32, M41
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
By Pepa Kraft
-
Financial Statement Recasting and Credit Risk Assessment
By George E. Batta, Ananda R. Ganguly, ...
-
Accounting Adjustments and the Valuation of Financial Statement Note Information in 10-K Filings
By Gus De Franco, M.h. Franco Wong, ...
-
Accounting Adjustments and the Valuation of Financial Statement Note Information in 10-K Filings
By Gus De Franco, M.h. Franco Wong, ...
-
Deeply and Persistently Conflicted: Credit Rating Agencies in the Current Regulatory Environment
-
Financial Reporting Quality and Uncertainty About Credit Risk Among the Credit Ratings Agencies
By Brian Akins
-
Financial Statement Comparability and Credit Risk
By Seil Kim, Pepa Kraft, ...
-
Credit Rating Agency and Equity Analysts' Adjustments to GAAP Earnings
By George E. Batta and Volkan Muslu