Permanent Earnings vs. Reported Earnings: Does the Average Difference Approximate Zero?
46 Pages Posted: 6 Feb 2012 Last revised: 30 Jul 2018
There are 2 versions of this paper
Earnings: Concepts vs. Reported
Date Written: June 20, 2012
Abstract
This paper evaluates the hypothesis that the difference between reported earnings and permanent earnings approximates zero, on average. We measure a firm’s permanent earnings using its stock price, and the short term interest rate determines the permanent earnings to price relation. The hypothesis corresponds to the idea that a firm’s capitalized reported earnings minus the stock price equals some “noise” which on average approximates zero. In valuation terms, the hypothesis depends on growth and risk cancelling each other, on average; our modeling does not depend on, or imply, risk-neutrality. US data supports the hypothesis: reported earnings exceed permanent earnings in about half of all cases. However, the proportion of pluses vs. minuses can deviate materially from 50% in any year, and there is marked time-series correlation. The “zero average” holds only because we evaluate several decades of data.
The permanent earnings hypothesis will not hold if the accounting approximates fair value accounting. Such accounting provides the underpinnings for Hick's concept of economic earnings, and it differs radically from traditional GAAP accounting. Per theory, economic earnings should exceed permanent earnings, on average. We consider this angle to the 50-50 proposition by examining financial firms. Earnings for such firms should to some extent tilt towards Hick’s earnings concept. The data supports the hypothesis: reported earnings now exceed the permanent earnings significantly more often than 50% of the time. Thus the benchmark permanent earnings hypothesis, the “fifty-fifty” proposition, applies only for industrial (non-financial) firms.
Keywords: Permanent earnings, economic earnings, reported earnings, short term risk free rate of interest, Fed model, earnings growth and risk cancelling out, industrial firms, financial firms
JEL Classification: M41
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Earnings Forecasts and the Predictability of Stock Returns:Evidence from Trading the S&P
By Athanasios Orphanides, Joel Lander, ...
-
Uncertainty on Monetary Policy and the Expectations Model of the Term Structure of Interest Rates
By Carlo A. Favero and Federico Mosca
-
Uncertainty on Monetary Policy and the Expectational Model of the Term Structure of Interest Rates
By Carlo A. Favero and Federico Mosca
-
Do Investors Expect Higher Returns from Safer Stocks than from Riskier Stocks?
-
Cointegration Analysis of the Fed Model
By Matti Koivu, Teemu Pennanen, ...
-
An International Analysis of Earnings, Stock Prices and Bond Yields
By Alain Durré and Pierre Giot
-
An International Analysis of Earnings, Stock Prices and Bond Yields
By Alain Durré and Pierre Giot