The Firm as the Locus of Social Comparisons: Internal Labor Markets Versus Up-or-Out
45 Pages Posted: 1 Mar 2012
There are 2 versions of this paper
The Firm as the Locus of Social Comparisons: Internal Labor Markets Versus Up-or-Out
Date Written: February 2012
Abstract
We suggest a parsimonious dynamic agency model in which workers have status concerns. A firm is a promotion hierarchy in which a workers status depends on past performance. We investigate the optimality of two types of promotion hierarchies: (i) internal labor markets, in which agents have a job guarantee, and (ii) 'up-or-out', in which agents are fired when unsuccessful. We show that up-or-out is optimal if success is difficult to achieve. When success is less hard to achieve, an internal labor market is optimal provided the payoffs associated with success are moderate. Otherwise, up-or-out is, again, optimal. These results are in line with observations from academia, law firms, investment banks and top consulting firms. Here, up-or-out dominates, while internal labor markets dominate where work is less demanding or payoffs are more compressed, for instance, because the environment is less competitive. We present some supporting evidence from academia, comparing US with French economics departments.
Keywords: Incentives, Promotion hierarchies, Sorting, Status
JEL Classification: J3, L2, M5
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Moral Hazard and Other-Regarding Preferences
By Hideshi Itoh
-
Envy and Compassion in Tournaments
By Christian Grund and Dirk Sliwka
-
Contracts and Inequity Aversion
By Florian Englmaier and Achim Wambach
-
Optimal Incentive Contracts Under Inequity Aversion
By Florian Englmaier and Achim Wambach
-
The Intensity of Incentives in Firms and Markets: Moral Hazard With Envious Agents
-
Optimal Incentive Contracts for a Worker Who Envies His Boss
By Robert Dur and Amihai Glazer
-
Output and Wages with Inequality Averse Agents
By Dominique Demougin, Claude Fluet, ...
-
Inequity Aversion in Tournaments
By Dominique Demougin and Claude Fluet
-
Optimal Contracts When Agents Envy Each Other
By Anjan V. Thakor and Anand M. Goel