Amnesties, Punishment and the Calibration of Mercy in Transition

Journal of Law and Society, 39(3), pp. 410-440, 2012

Transitional Justice Institute Research Paper No. 12-07

24 Pages Posted: 8 Sep 2012

See all articles by Louise Mallinder

Louise Mallinder

Queen's University Belfast

Kieran McEvoy

Queen's University Belfast - School of Law

Date Written: 2012

Abstract

Despite the much vaunted triumph of human rights, amnesties continue to be a much used technique of post conflict transitional justice. For many critics, they are a synonymous with unaccountability and injustice. Using a number of key frameworks in the punishment and society literature – retribution, deterrence and restoration – this article examines some of those assumptions. The paper argues that despite the rhetoric, there is no universal duty to prosecute under international law and that issues of selectivity and proportionality present serious challenges to the retributive rationale for punishment in international justice. It contends that many of the assumptions concerning the deterrent effect in the field are also oversold and poorly theorised. It also suggests that appropriately designed restorative amnesties can be both lawful and effective as routes to truth recovery, reconciliation and a range of other peacemaking goals. The paper concludes that rather than viewing amnesties as mere instruments of impunity, they should instead be seen as important institutions in the governance of mercy, the reassertion of state sovereignty and, if properly constituted, the return of law to a previously lawless domain.

Keywords: Amnesties, Transition

Suggested Citation

Mallinder, Louise and McEvoy, Kieran, Amnesties, Punishment and the Calibration of Mercy in Transition (2012). Journal of Law and Society, 39(3), pp. 410-440, 2012, Transitional Justice Institute Research Paper No. 12-07, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2143179

Louise Mallinder (Contact Author)

Queen's University Belfast ( email )

School of Law
Belfast, County (optional) BT1 7NN
United Kingdom
02890973470 (Phone)

Kieran McEvoy

Queen's University Belfast - School of Law ( email )

School of Law
Belfast BT7 1NN, BT7 1NN
Ireland

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
319
Abstract Views
1,287
Rank
173,430
PlumX Metrics