Irrational Women: Informed Consent and Abortion Regret

Tracy A. Thomas & Tracey Jean Boisseau, eds., Feminist Legal History: Essays on Women and Law (NYU Press 2011)

25 Pages Posted: 24 Feb 2013

See all articles by Maya Manian

Maya Manian

American University - Washington College of Law

Date Written: 2011

Abstract

This chapter explores the law’s failure in the twenty-first century to treat pregnant women as capable of making their own decisions concerning whether to have an abortion. The Supreme Court’s 2007 decision in Gonzales v. Carhart, which upheld a federal ban on a type of second-trimester abortion that many physicians believe is safest for their patients, brought the question of women’s capacity for abortion decision-making to the forefront of public legal consciousness. In Carhart, the Court abandoned its previous deference and respect for a woman’s right to be her own decision-maker with regard to abortion and instead determined that a pregnant woman lacks capacity to make her own decisions and give informed consent to abortion-related medical treatment. According to the Court, the government may make the final decision regarding a pregnant woman’s healthcare to ensure that she realizes her “ultimate” role as a mother. This chapter recounts the contradictory history in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries of abortion law’s regard for women’s agency as decision-makers. It also argues that Carhart’s disrespect for women’s decision-making abilities unjustifiably diverges from the law’s deference to patient healthcare decision-making more generally. The unequal treatment of women as healthcare decision-makers bolsters the argument articulated by feminist legal scholars that abortion restrictions manifest sex discrimination.

Keywords: reproductive health, constitutional law, abortion, pregnancy, women's health, Gonzales v. Carhart, health law, sex discrimination

Suggested Citation

Manian, Maya, Irrational Women: Informed Consent and Abortion Regret (2011). Tracy A. Thomas & Tracey Jean Boisseau, eds., Feminist Legal History: Essays on Women and Law (NYU Press 2011), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2222961

Maya Manian (Contact Author)

American University - Washington College of Law ( email )

4300 Nebraska Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20016
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
115
Abstract Views
1,391
Rank
433,058
PlumX Metrics