International Criminal Justice, the Gotovina Judgment and the Making of Refugees

Posted: 19 Apr 2013

See all articles by Rosemary Byrne

Rosemary Byrne

Trinity College (Dublin) - Institute for International Integration Studies (IIIS)

Gregor Noll

Gothenburg University, School of Economics, Business and Law

Date Written: April 19, 2013

Abstract

In this paper, we shall present two interlocking arguments, both drawing on a distinction between formal and substantive models of justice. In a first step, we depart from the accepted presumptions about the formal delivery of international criminal justice and its capacities to deliver peace and security, to consider how alternative views on the legitimacy of international criminal tribunals and retributive justice present some far more unsettling perspectives about the performance and promise of these nascent courts. If these issues are taken seriously, then one should reconsider whether international trials are able to deliver the broader forms of substantive justice that might provide a more effective means of mitigating refugee displacement. In a second step, we then consider why the ICTY’s reasoning in the Gotovina case will remain unable to prevent future ethnic cleansing, as the trial paradigm does not invite judges to address the broader substantive questions as to how deeply divided communities are to live with each other. Worse still, the Gotovina acquittal by the Appeals Chamber risks to entrench the idea that the massive abuses, considered to constitute ‘persecution’ by the Trial Chamber, may be unleashed with impunity under cover of an armed conflict.

Keywords: Gotovina, international criminal law, persecution, refugees

Suggested Citation

Byrne, Rosemary and Noll, Gregor, International Criminal Justice, the Gotovina Judgment and the Making of Refugees (April 19, 2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2253870 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2253870

Rosemary Byrne

Trinity College (Dublin) - Institute for International Integration Studies (IIIS) ( email )

The Sutherland Centre, Level 6, Arts Building
Trinity College
Dublin 2
Ireland

Gregor Noll (Contact Author)

Gothenburg University, School of Economics, Business and Law ( email )

Gothenburg
Sweden

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
84
Abstract Views
582
Rank
535,566
PlumX Metrics