A Semiotic Critique of the Scientific Status of Psychiatry and the Contribution of Psychiatric Evaluation in the Formation of Judicial Judgment

21 Pages Posted: 15 Aug 2013

Date Written: August 14, 2013

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to expose the pseudo-scientific status of psychiatry as a legitimate discipline, capable of exerting considerable influence on and occasionally constituting the sole source whereupon judicial decisions are based. By drawing on Peircean semiotics, and particularly on the triadic classification and posited inter-relationship between sign-object-interpretant and the role of abduction in formulating and testing hypotheses, and by comparing and contrasting this aspect of Peircean semiotics with the rhetoric popularized by the so-called medical (or psycho-pharmaceutical) model, it will be shown that not only ‘mental illness’ is essentially a metaphorical construct without any diagnosable ‘reality’ (a standpoint that was raised, emphasized and popularized as early as 1961 by Szasz in his seminal work "The Myth of Mental Illness") and ‘objective grounding’ in the bio-chemical processes of the brain, but that the non-falsifiable pseudo-objectivism of psychiatric rhetoric by virtue of naturalizing inherently semiotic phenomena is prone and highly conducive to severe violations of the criminal law, involving, but not being restricted to, falsification of medical records and intentionally leading astray judicial opinion.

Suggested Citation

Rossolatos, George, A Semiotic Critique of the Scientific Status of Psychiatry and the Contribution of Psychiatric Evaluation in the Formation of Judicial Judgment (August 14, 2013). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2310155 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2310155

George Rossolatos (Contact Author)

University of Kassel ( email )

Fachbereich 05
Nora-Platiel-Straße 1
34109 Kassel, Hessen 34127
Germany

HOME PAGE: http://grossolatos.blogspot.com/

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
75
Abstract Views
744
Rank
571,914
PlumX Metrics