Effective Plea Bargains for Noncitizens

The Scholar Vol. 16, pp. 607-629 (2014)

24 Pages Posted: 10 Oct 2014

Date Written: September 2, 2014

Abstract

In Padilla v. Kentucky, the United States Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment requires criminal defense attorneys to advise non-citizen clients regarding the deportation risks associated with a guilty plea. The Court held in that case that a defendant's guilty plea may be involuntarily made when defense counsel fails to advise the client about those deportation risks. Trial judges accepting guilty pleas from criminal defendants have a duty to confirm the defendant makes the plea voluntarily and intelligently. Judges make this determination through the plea colloquy -- a series of admonishments and questions with the pleading defendant done prior to accepting the plea. Padilla at a minimum requires trial judges to inquire whether or not the defendant is a non-citizen, and if so, whether the defendant has received the correct advice regarding the guilty plea's immigration consequences. The judge's failure to do so may result in a conviction tainted by ineffective assistance or supported by a plea not voluntarily and intelligently made.

This Article suggests trial judges should take affirmative steps prior to accepting a non-citizen's plea to reveal whether counsel has provided relevant and correct immigration advice to the defendant. Part I discusses Padilla's facts, rationale and holding, Part II discusses the requirement for a voluntary and intelligently made guilty plea in modern plea bargain jurisprudence and Part III discusses the process for obtaining post-conviction relief for Sixth Amendment violations under Strickland v. Washington's ineffective assistance standard. Part IV closes by discussing best practices for trial judges and counsel to safeguard a non-citizen's rights while developing a record that anticipates post-conviction Sixth Amendment claims.

Keywords: Immigration, Padilla, Plea Bargains, Criminal Law

JEL Classification: K14

Suggested Citation

Estlinbaum, Craig, Effective Plea Bargains for Noncitizens (September 2, 2014). The Scholar Vol. 16, pp. 607-629 (2014), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2498701

Craig Estlinbaum (Contact Author)

The Crisis Center ( email )

P. O. Box 1820
Bay City, TX 77404
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
82
Abstract Views
763
Rank
543,429
PlumX Metrics