Human Dignity in Adjudication: The Limits of Placeholding and Essential Contestability Accounts

22 Pages Posted: 25 Jan 2016

See all articles by Pritam Baruah

Pritam Baruah

BML Munjal University School of Law

Date Written: September 1, 2013

Abstract

Employing moral values as justifications in judicial decisions has been controversial. At present, there is increasing controversy over the application of human dignity. Contemporary debates on the role of dignity in law and adjudication are heavily influenced by Christopher McCrudden’s account of dignity as a placeholder, and much thinking on the contested nature of values is influenced by WB Gallie’s idea of Essentially Contested Concepts. In this paper I argue that both these accounts have limited explanatory and normative potential. McCrudden’s account is illuminating in terms of the role of dignity in the UDHR, but weak in terms of explaining why employing dignity in adjudication yields diverging conclusions, and why dignity should be understood to be a placeholder. His reliance on Gallie’s idea of Essentially Contested Concepts is also misplaced. Gallie’s views often serve as a philosophical basis for understanding the contested nature of values generally. I argue that his account is an external-descriptive one, which cannot explain why persistent disagreement ensues because of the peculiar nature of some concepts. Neither does it point out any property of essential contestability that is unique to some concepts. Thinking on how values such as dignity can figure as justifications for decisions, therefore, must explore other alternatives.

Keywords: Human Dignity, Essentially Contested Concepts, Adjudication, Reason-Giving, Philosophy of Law

Suggested Citation

Baruah, Pritam, Human Dignity in Adjudication: The Limits of Placeholding and Essential Contestability Accounts (September 1, 2013). Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, Vol. 27, No. 2, 2014, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2547901

Pritam Baruah (Contact Author)

BML Munjal University School of Law ( email )

National Highway 8
67 KM Milestone
Gurgaon
India

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
98
Abstract Views
501
Rank
486,005
PlumX Metrics