The Functional and the Dysfunctional in the Comparative Method of Law: Some Critical Remarks

(2008) 12.3 Electronic Journal of Comparative Law

16 Pages Posted: 13 May 2015 Last revised: 30 May 2015

See all articles by Antonios Platsas

Antonios Platsas

National Research University Higher School of Economics (Moscow) - Faculty of Law

Date Written: May 12, 2015

Abstract

This contribution explores the leading principle in the comparative method of law: functionality of comparisons. The principle is defined, conditioned and analysed. In particular, the author wishes to maintain with this article the orthodox approach when it comes to understanding the principle of functionality for the comparative method. The article’s analysis proceeds with an examination of whether functionality is concerned with similarities and/or differences. The author suggests that it is possible that functionality can operate for the identification of differences and the identification of similarities, the stress being on the latter. The article then argues that functionality serves as a common, unifying and mutually intelligible denominator amongst comparative lawyers around the world, even though not necessarily in a dogmatic fashion. Furthermore, the author of this contribution notes the evolution of the principle in question, its strengths as well as its main criticisms, which are also presented herein. The article concludes that functionality remains the epicentre of the comparative method of law and that its drawbacks remind us that the principle is susceptible to further refinement in the future.

Keywords: comparative legal method, comparative methodology, comparative law, functionality, comparability

Suggested Citation

Platsas, Antonios, The Functional and the Dysfunctional in the Comparative Method of Law: Some Critical Remarks (May 12, 2015). (2008) 12.3 Electronic Journal of Comparative Law, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2605476

Antonios Platsas (Contact Author)

National Research University Higher School of Economics (Moscow) - Faculty of Law ( email )

3 Bolshoy Trekhsvyatitelskiy Str.
Moscow, 109028
Russia
+7 495 7729590*23102 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.hse.ru/en/org/persons/133709507

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
114
Abstract Views
564
Rank
435,891
PlumX Metrics