Bankruptcy-Remote Transactions and Bankruptcy Law — A Comparative Approach (Part 1): Changing the Focus on Vehicle Shielding

Capital Markets Law Journal, (2015) 10 (2): 239-274.

36 Pages Posted: 18 Feb 2016

See all articles by David Ramos Muñoz

David Ramos Muñoz

Universidad Carlos III de Madrid; EUSFIL Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence

Date Written: March 29, 2015

Abstract

Conventional wisdom about bankruptcy-remote transactions tends to be grounded on two assumptions. First, bankruptcy-remote transactions are a highly specific, and borderline case, of anecdotal relevance for bankruptcy policy. Second, bankruptcy-remote transactions are either a welcome or dangerous innovation, with little scope for nuances. This article tries to examine the relationship of bankruptcy-remote transactions and bankruptcy policy in a new light, using precedent and scholarly analysis from different jurisdictions.

First, the article establishes the different ideas encompassed by the concept of ‘bankruptcy remoteness’, and puts bankruptcy-remote structures in the broader context of bankruptcy policy. Second, the article uses the ‘vehicle-shielding’ concept of bankruptcy-remoteness and tests traditional legal threats such as avoidance, re-characterization or substantive consolidation, seeing whether their academic importance from an academic perspective is matched by their relevance as a threat in practice. Third, the article analyses the instances where vehicle shielding has actually been, or can be, put in jeopardy, and the reasons for it. The article concludes that bankruptcy-remote transactions should cease to be considered a marginal case for bankruptcy law. Rather, the tensions between different goals, at the core of bankruptcy policy, are very present in the context of these transactions, only such tensions materialize in ways different from that those originally envisaged. Academic analysis should adjust to this complex reality, rather than the opposite.

Keywords: securitization, bankruptcy, policy, vehicle, SPV, special purpose, characterization, consolidation, substantive

JEL Classification: K11, K22

Suggested Citation

Ramos Muñoz, David, Bankruptcy-Remote Transactions and Bankruptcy Law — A Comparative Approach (Part 1): Changing the Focus on Vehicle Shielding (March 29, 2015). Capital Markets Law Journal, (2015) 10 (2): 239-274., Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2733613

David Ramos Muñoz (Contact Author)

Universidad Carlos III de Madrid ( email )

126, Getafe
Madrid, 28903
Spain

HOME PAGE: http://www.uc3m.es

EUSFIL Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence ( email )

Italy

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
181
Abstract Views
996
Rank
300,399
PlumX Metrics