The Tension between Genome Privacy and Criminal Justice in the Wake of DNA Databases

Journal of Penal Law and Criminology 2017; 5 (2):163-178

16 Pages Posted: 7 Dec 2017

See all articles by Rahime Erbaş

Rahime Erbaş

Istanbul University - Faculty of Law

Date Written: December 2, 2017

Abstract

Using DNA databases has a significant role in finding truths in criminal law; therefore, national DNA databases are becoming common worldwide. Consequently, their size is increasing every year. However, do we actually need a DNA database for the sake of criminal justice? Within this context, this study first demonstrates how common it is to create DNA databases today and how much information is retained in these databases. Then, the key question emerges: how do we find the balance between the competing interests of ensuring the right to privacy while facilitating the state’s interest in solving crimes? This is where the main implementation criteria for data entry, storage and destruction become significant. More concretely, we examine the criteria that should be adopted around whether DNA samples for particular criminals should be included. For example, should DNA samples be included in the case of serious crimes, e.g., crimes against life, sexual abuse, and robbery, as well as crimes requiring punishment of more than a certain time period, such as more than one year? Further, is it possible to remove DNA information from the database? This study is based on the proposal that these criteria play a significant role in softening the tension between breaching privacy and the State's interest in fighting and solving crimes. This study will focus on these criteria, summarized as data entry, storage and destruction by considering comparative law including the EU, the ECHR and the USA analysis.

Keywords: Genome, DNA, Databank, storage, privacy, crime, criminal procedure, Prüm Convention, the EU member countries, the USA, the ECHR, S and Marper vs. United Kingdom, Maryland vs. King

JEL Classification: K14

Suggested Citation

Erbaş, Rahime, The Tension between Genome Privacy and Criminal Justice in the Wake of DNA Databases (December 2, 2017). Journal of Penal Law and Criminology 2017; 5 (2):163-178, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3081456

Rahime Erbaş (Contact Author)

Istanbul University - Faculty of Law ( email )

TR-34116 Istanbul
Turkey

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
108
Abstract Views
1,193
Rank
454,063
PlumX Metrics