When Many Davids Collaborate with One Goliath: How Inter-Organizational Networks (Fail to) Manage Size Differentials
British Journal of Management, Forthcoming
36 Pages Posted: 9 Jun 2018
Date Written: May 23, 2018
Abstract
How do organizations of vastly different size collaborate in order to achieve a common goal? While this poses less of a problem when the network is orchestrated by a classic lead firm, in networks exhibiting a shared governance mode, where leadership responsibilities are more or less equally distributed, size differentials present a critical management challenge. In this paper, we contribute to the literature on coordination in and of inter-organizational arrangements by emphasizing the so far largely neglected role of size for managing close collaborative relationships. We study the case of Apprenticeship Network, a network that originally consisted of seven small and medium-sized enterprises, but which then accepted a very large multinational firm as a new member. By unpacking how the network coordinated its endeavor over time to achieve accountability, predictability, and a common understanding as critical conditions for effective coordination, we explore how coordination effectiveness may deteriorate and result in the failure of the collaborative effort. We pay special attention to the role of size in these processes, and we theorize how the strategic front- and back-staging of agreed-upon rules and norms facilitates the formation, maintenance, and deletion of a tie, thus producing important network dynamics.
Keywords: Organizational Size, Inter-Organizational Networks and Multi-Partner Alliances, Coordination, Network Dynamics, Failure
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation