The Costs of Having (Too) Many Choices: Reshaping the Doctrine of Informed Consent

51 Pages Posted: 9 Nov 2018

See all articles by Maytal Gilboa

Maytal Gilboa

Bar-Ilan University - Faculty of Law

Omer Pelled

Bar Ilan University School of Law

Date Written: November 4, 2018

Abstract

This article suggests a reshaping of the doctrine of informed consent to accommodate the potential costs of choices vis-à-vis patients’ wellbeing. Applying insights from psychology and behavioral economics, it makes four main claims. First, the current doctrine imposes a broad duty of disclosure on physicians toward their patients, based on the premise that the patients want and need to know all the alternative treatments for their ailment. We argue that this premise is misguided. Choice-making processes are not cost-free. Since patients incur costs when they must choose a treatment from too many alternatives, the current duty should be narrowed. Second, when a physician violates the duty of disclosure, the patient can recover damages only if he or she suffers resultant physical harm. However, since scientific evidence shows that patients draw benefits from the process of choosing their treatment, regardless of the treatment they ultimately choose, we argue that once the duty of disclosure is breached, the patient should be entitled to damages for the loss of this benefit even in the absence of any physical harm. Third, when courts award damages, the plaintiff is awarded full compensation for his or her physical harm. We argue that this compensation should be offset by the benefit caused by the physician’s breach of the duty to disclose, which is the cost associated with the process of choosing. Fourth and last, as the costs and benefits of choice making may differ from one patient to another, the doctrine should be sensitive to the preferences of the particular patient. Hence, we suggest that patients be offered the possibility of opting out of the extensive informed consent regime and be offered fewer alternatives if they wish.

Keywords: torts, duty to disclose, informed consent, medical malpractice, choice making

JEL Classification: K13, K32, I12

Suggested Citation

Gilboa, Maytal and Pelled, Omer, The Costs of Having (Too) Many Choices: Reshaping the Doctrine of Informed Consent (November 4, 2018). Brooklyn Law Review , Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3278109

Maytal Gilboa

Bar-Ilan University - Faculty of Law ( email )

Faculty of Law
Ramat Gan, 52900
Israel

Omer Pelled (Contact Author)

Bar Ilan University School of Law ( email )

Ramat Gan, 52900
Israel

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
143
Abstract Views
890
Rank
366,674
PlumX Metrics