Opening the Black Box: Structural Factor Models Versus Structural Vars
29 Pages Posted: 18 Dec 2003
Date Written: December 2003
Abstract
In this Paper, we study identification in dynamic factor models and argue that factor models are better suited than VARs to provide a structural representation of the macroeconomy. Factor models distinguish measurement errors and other idiosyncratic disturbances from structural macroeconomic shocks. As a consequence, the number of structural shocks is no longer equal to the number of variables included in the information set. In practice, the number of structural shocks turns out to be small, so that only a few restrictions are needed to reach identification. Economic interpretation is then easier. On the other hand, with factor models we can handle much larger information sets - including virtually all existing macroeconomic information. This solves the problems of superior information and fundamentality and enables us to analyse the effects of the shocks on all macroeconomic variables. In the empirical illustration, we study a set of 89 US macroeconomic time series, including the series analysed in the seminal paper of King et al. (1991). We find that the system of impulse response functions of these series is non-fundamental and, therefore, cannot be estimated with a VAR. Moreover, unlike in King et al. (1991), the impulse response functions of the permanent shock are monotonic and, therefore, more credible if the permanent shock is interpreted as technical change.
Keywords: Dynamic factor models, structural VARs, identification
JEL Classification: C10, E00
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Generalized Dynamic Factor Model: One-Sided Estimation and Forecasting
By Mario Forni, Marc Hallin, ...
-
Arbitrage, Factor Structure, and Mean-Variance Analysis on Large Asset Markets
-
By James H. Stock and Mark W. Watson
-
Monetary Policy in a Data-Rich Environment
By Ben S. Bernanke and Jean Boivin
-
Eurocoin: A Real Time Coincident Indicator of the Euro Area Business Cycle
By Filippo Altissimo, Antonio Bassanetti, ...
-
Are More Data Always Better for Factor Analysis?
By Jean Boivin and Serena Ng
-
Implications of Dynamic Factor Models for VAR Analysis
By James H. Stock and Mark W. Watson
-
By Domenico Giannone, Lucrezia Reichlin, ...
-
By Domenico Giannone, Lucrezia Reichlin, ...