Box Spread Arbitrage Profits Following the 1987 Market Crash: Real or Illusory?
J. OF FINANCIAL AND QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS, March 1997
Posted: 10 Apr 1997
Abstract
We examine market efficiency before and after the 1987 Market Crash using the box spread strategy implemented with European-style S&P~500 Index (SPX) options. Before the Crash, apparent arbitrage opportunities were rare and simulated trades were unprofitable assuming a one-minute execution delay. After the Crash, apparent arbitrage opportunities were frequent and simulated trades were profitable even assuming a five-minute execution delay. Our analysis makes the routine assumption that quotes are good until updated to construct a time series of prevailing quotes sampled at 30-second intervals. If this assumption is valid, then arbitrage profits were actually available. If this assumption is invalid, then such profits could have been illusory. Either scenario, however, implies that SPX market efficiency decreased following the Crash---prevailing price quotes repeatedly failed to satisfy the fundamental parity relation underlying the box spread.
JEL Classification: G13, G14
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation