Regulation by Generalization
31 Pages Posted: 15 Nov 2005
Date Written: August 2005
Abstract
Both criminal and regulatory law have traditionally been skeptical of what Jeremy Bentham referred to as evidentiary offenses - the prohibition (or regulation) of some activity not because it is wrong, but because it probabilistically (but not universally) indicates that a real wrong has occurred. From Bentham to the present, courts and theorists have worried about this form of regulation, believing that certainly in the criminal law context but even with respect to regulation it is wrong to impose sanctions on a "where there's smoke there's fire" theory of governmental intervention. Yet although this kind punishment by proxy continues to be held in disrepute, both in courts and in the literature, we argue that this distaste is unwarranted. Regulating - even through the criminal law - by regulating intrinsically innocent activities that probabilistically but not inexorably indicate not-so-innocent activities is no different from the vast number of other probabilistic elements that pervade the regulatory process. Once we recognize the frequency with which we accept probabilistic but not certain burdens of proof, probabilistic but not certain substantive rules, and probabilistic but not certain pieces of evidence, we can see that defining offenses and regulatory targets in terms of non-wrongful behavior that is evidence of wrongful behavior is neither surprising nor inadvisable.
Keywords: Business and Government Policy, Crime and Criminal Justice, Economics - Microeconomics, Environment and Natural Resources, Law and Legal Institutions, Regulation
JEL Classification: H00
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Distance, Skill Deepening and Development: Will Peripheral Countries Ever Get Rich?
-
Distance, Skill Deepening and Development: Will Peripheral Countries Ever Get Rich?
-
Can Australia Match US Productivity Performance?
By Ben Dolman, Dean Parham, ...
-
The Contribution of Economic Geography to GDP Per Capita
By Herve Boulhol, Alain De Serres, ...
-
Skills, Agglomeration and Segmentation
By Tomoya Mori and Alessandro Turrini
-
Have Developed Countries Escaped the Curse of Distance?
By Herve Boulhol and Alain De Serres