Regional Variation in Rental Costs for Larger Households
Motu Working Paper No. 05-02
52 Pages Posted: 23 Jun 2006
Date Written: May 2005
Abstract
Housing costs comprise a major part of most household budgets. Larger households require greater space than do smaller households but do not necessarily have larger incomes. The cost of extra housing space (e.g. the cost of an extra bedroom) may vary across different locations, both absolutely (dollars per week) and proportionately (percentage of overall costs). If this is the case, differential regional costs of additional space may provide an incentive for different sized households to locate in particular areas where housing costs most appropriately fit their needs. Our analysis uses tenancy bond rental data to analyse the cost of renting an extra bedroom in different locations throughout New Zealand. It discusses the theory of what determines rents. We then examine the nature of regional rental costs, testing whether the documented patterns fit with theoretical predictions. Finally, we reflect on what the results may imply for social outcomes and housing policy in New Zealand. To give a flavour of the issues, consider the following. In 2003, the average weekly rental cost of a two bedroom dwelling in Auckland was $37 more than for a one bedroom dwelling. The cost of a third bedroom was an extra $50 and the cost of a fourth bedroom was an additional $90. Thus weekly rental cost for a four bedroom dwelling exceeded that of a one bedroom dwelling by $177. In Manawatu-Wanganui, the cost of a two bedroom dwelling was $38 more than for a one bedroom dwelling - almost identical to the margin in Auckland. But the cost of additional bedrooms was much lower than in Auckland: $29 for a third bedroom and $33 for a fourth bedroom. This raw data might suggest that it would be beneficial for larger households to locate in Manawatu-Wanganui and for smaller households to locate in Auckland. However, the interaction with other factors has to be taken into account before such a conclusion can be reached. At the minimum, the data suggests there is a material issue to be addressed relating to disparities in regional housing costs for different sized households.
Keywords: House Rents, Deprivation, Regional Disparities
JEL Classification: R21, R31, R51
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Housing and Economic Adjustment
By Arthur Grimes, Suzi Kerr, ...
-
House Price Efficiency: Expectations, Sales, Symmetry
By Arthur Grimes, Andrew Aitken, ...
-
What's the Beef with House Prices? Economic Shocks and Local Housing Markets
By Arthur Grimes and Andrew Aitken
-
By David C. Maré and Jason Craig Timmins
-
Land Taxes and Revenue Needs as Communities Grow and Decline: Evidence from New Zealand
By Suzi Kerr, Andrew Aitken, ...
-
Adjustment in Local Labour and Housing Markets
By Arthur Grimes, David C. Maré, ...
-
Insolvency and Economic Development: Regional Variation and Adjustment
By Richard Fabling and Arthur Grimes
-
House Prices and Rents: Socio-Economic Impacts and Prospects
By Arthur Grimes and Andrew Aitken
-
Passing the Buck: Impacts of Commodity Price Shocks on Local Outcomes
By Arthur Grimes and Sean Hyland