The Contractarian Theory of Corporate Law: A Generation Later
20 Pages Posted: 16 Jan 2007
Abstract
This article analyzes the extent to which contractarian analysis of corporate law has stood up to a generation of scholarship in law and economics - particularly empirical scholarship. It concludes that while the contractarian theory remains a useful starting point, more recent research demonstrates that as a description of reality or a basis for policy prescription, the theory falls short. Two phenomena reflect shortcomings in the contractarian theory. First, corporate contracts exhibit a high degree of uniformity - in Delaware incorporation and in the adoption of default rules. Second, customization and innovation in corporate governance have occurred in noncontractual form - that is, without legally binding commitments to maintain them. The positive implication is that there are apparently impediments to the creation of legally binding governance commitments. Those impediments may undermine the contractarian link between contract and social optimality. The normative implication is that the minimalist view of corporate law - that everything can be left to customized contracting - is questionable. A menu approach to the design of corporate law may be more effective than either the default rule structure that the contractarian theory prescribes or an approach of mandatory regulation.
Keywords: corporate law, corporate governance, contract, contractarian
JEL Classification: G30, G34, K22, K00
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Aligning Incentives with Equity: Employee Stock Options and Rule 10b-5
-
Employee Primacy, or Economics Meets Civic Republicanism at Work
-
Branded: Corporate Image, Sexual Stereotyping, and the New Face of Capitalism
By Dianne Avery and Marion G. Crain
-
By Érica Gorga and Michael Halberstam
-
Trademarks and the Boundaries of the Firm
By Dan L. Burk and Brett Mcdonnell
-
An Empirical Examination of Business Outsourcing Transactions