Probability Elicitation, Scoring Rules, and Competition Among Forecasters
23 Pages Posted: 5 Feb 2007
Date Written: January 21, 2007
Abstract
Probability forecasters who are rewarded via a proper scoring rule may care not only about the score, but also about their performance relative to other forecasters. We model this type of preference and show that a competitive forecaster who wants to do better than another forecaster typically should report more extreme probabilities, exaggerating toward zero or one. We consider a competitive forecaster's best response to truthful reporting and also investigate equilibrium reporting functions in the case where another forecaster also cares about relative performance. We show how a decision maker can revise probabilities of an event after receiving reported probabilities from competitive forecasters and note that the strategy of exaggerating probabilities can make well-calibrated forecasters (and a decision maker who takes their reported probabilities at face value) appear to be overconfident. However, a decision maker who adjusts appropriately for the misrepresentation of probabilities by one or more forecasters can still be well-calibrated. Finally, to try to overcome the forecasters' competitive instincts and induce cooperative behavior, we develop the notion of joint scoring rules based on business sharing and show that these scoring rules are strictly proper.
Keywords: probability elicitation; scoring rules; forecasting competitions; probability forecasts; truthful revelation; overconfidence bias
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Dynamics of the Federal Funds Target Rate: A Nonstationary Discrete Choice Approach
By Ling Hu and Peter C. B. Phillips
-
By Ling Hu and Peter C. B. Phillips
-
Maximum Score Estimation of a Nonstationary Binary Choice Model
-
Dynamic Limited Dependent Variable Modeling and US Monetary Policy
-
Recovering Market Expectations of FOMC Rate Changes With Options on Federal Funds Futures
By John B. Carlson, Ben R. Craig, ...
-
Forecast Combination for Discrete Choice Models: Predicting FOMC Monetary Policy Decisions
-
Nonstationary Discrete Choice: A Corrigendum and Addendum
By Peter C. B. Phillips, Sainan Jin, ...
-
A Study of a Semiparametric Binary Choice Model with Integrated Covariates