The Binding Force of Babel: The Enforcement of EC Law Unpublished in the Languages of the New Member States (Extended Version)
Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, Vol. 9, pp. 43-80, 2007
28 Pages Posted: 26 Jun 2007 Last revised: 11 Jan 2014
Date Written: November 30, 2010
Abstract
This paper explores some of the issues raised by the absence of due publication of EC secondary legislation in the languages of the new Member States after the 2004 Accession. It first lays down some general principles regarding the publication of legal acts in Community law, pertinent to the current situation. Second, it addresses specific derogations from this regime brought about by Accession. With the help of some general principles governing the publication and communication of legal norms in EC law and in the Member States, it tries to suggest a possible approach to address the extraordinary situation following the 2004 enlargement. It takes into account the consequences of the proposed solution and the potential sequels on the national level, especially before the constitutional courts of the new Member States. Finally, it draws some conclusions regarding publication of legislation in the European Union and the future of legislative linguistic pluralism.
Keywords: European law, publication of secondary legislation, languages, Accession, absence of publication, validity, enforceability
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation